Chris Walsh (chris_walsh) wrote,
Chris Walsh

Red Tails

I went into Red Tails -- the George Lucas-produced World War II film about the Tuskegee Airmen, pioneering African-American pilots, and when they finally started to see air combat -- with carefully-ratcheted expectations, based on the reviews. I can handle old-fashioned and corny, and knew this film had that in spades, as well as "rah rah war can be awesome" cheerleading. You don't see that often in films these past few decades. Even 1990's Memphis Belle, which looks old-fashioned, is more a modern-era "war sucks and we really wish we could find a better way to handle conflict" story.

Except for one quick line, Red Tails skips any "war is hell" rhetoric and goes straight to two problems: people thinking African-Americans couldn't fly (pointed out in a 1920s military study quoted at the very start), and in Scene 1, an immediate problem of fighter escorts not properly escorting their bombers, because the fighters fly off to dogfight with the Germans. Many B-17s go blow-up-y due to that, and pretty on-the-nose dialogue explains it. How oh how will both problems be solved? Quick cut to the Tuskegee Airmen, who (spoiler!) save the day, break some bricks out of the wall of prejudice, banter, fall in love (a pilot named Lightning falls for an Italian girl), and sometimes die, because it's war, a war that killed tens of millions of people (though how many non-Nazis died in this film? Two?).

The people who made Red Tails -- producers George Lucas and Chas. Floyd Johnson, director Anthony Hemingway, writers John Ridley and Aaron McGruder, and it seems like half the cast of The Wire -- have all done better work. I was there for flight-y, shoot-y, explode-y fun, and on that level, as I figured I would, I enjoyed it. But still, better work's been done. But-but, blowing up Nazis For The Win (literally)! I got behind that.

Also, apparently, according to Red Tails, there was only one World War II German pilot with a face. One chiseled, scary, hates-all-good-people face.
Tags: film reviews

  • Before Tori Amos was Tori Amos

    Tori Amos's first album was, for a long time, hard to find, and no, I'm not talking about 1991's Little Earthquakes, I'm talking about 1988's Y…

  • If his voice and soul had been with us longer...

    Howard Ashman. He was a songwriter, stage show book writer and, later, film producer. He was one of the reasons there are 1982's Little Shop of…

  • Soundtrack considerations

    What to listen to while reading Book [X]? I wouldn't want the music I put on to distract from whichever book I'm reading; plenty of books I can…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.