Chris Walsh (chris_walsh) wrote,
Chris Walsh

The right song in the right place

There's a subtle art to choosing the right songs for a film or TV soundtrack. Not that it seems subtle the umpteenth time a film plays "Sympathy for the Devil."* The goal often is to find songs that maybe not everyone knows or remembers, but which work in unexpected and subtle ways. That's hard to do, as a song's narrative could conflict with the film or show's narrative. A drama like Brokeback Mountain wouldn't and shouldn't have songs like, say, The Bloodhound Gang's "The Bad Touch." Watchmen's use of "Hallelujah" by Leonard Cohen is a famously bad example, trying to add dramatic weight to a sex scene that the scene can't quite support. Yes, the filmmakers could have chosen better.

Subtle is possible. Even when it doesn't seem subtle, like the "Awesome Mix" of songs from the first Guardians of the Galaxy**, it still can be: those songs tell you a lot about Peter Quill's relationship with his mother, and how they both probably liked certain songs without quite listening to all the lyrics.

I'm writing this because I keep wondering how a film could use this.

Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds' "The Mercy Seat." A song about a man getting executed in the electric chair. Explicitly about it. And the song sounds huge. The song's drama would most likely overwhelm any scene's drama. How to avoid that?

Go in a comedy direction. Have a montage of characters listening on headphones to songs to get them to relax. Someone's listening to "Here Comes the Sun"; someone else is listening to Pachelbel's "Canon"; someone else is listening to "The Mercy Seat."

I like that image.

* One time it wasn't: the film version of Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas doesn't use that song, even though Hunter S. Thompson mentioned "Sympathy for the Devil" when the book opens. The filmmakers decided it was too slow for the specific kind of energy they wanted in the scene. "Combination of the Two" by Big Brother and the Holding Company, with vocals by Janis Joplin, did have the right energy. In fact, Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas has a really well-chosen soundtrack, in case you've never heard it.

** I'm fond of that blog entry. *nods*
Tags: music

  • On this cold night, Out-Of-Context Theater.

    “We told you, maple syrup osmosis is not a thing…”

  • DUNE. Done.

    Just finished my first full read-through of Frank Herbert’s Dune series. I re-read the original back in July 2020; tonight, I finished Hunters of…

  • Re-Memory

    Re-Memory by Christopher Walsh, 7/31/2022-1/2/2023 I think I smoked in a past life. It’s as if my never-smoked-a-cigarette self can Somehow…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.