The Robert Rodriguez half, Planet Terror, where military-skullduggery-gone-wrong turns many small-town Texans into zombies, feels like a script cobbled together from a bunch of other scripts; that’s one way to explain the hey-it’s-like-we’re-joining-another-film-a
But while I enjoyed the insanity of Planet Terror, I was transported (no lie) by Quentin Tarantino’s half of the experience, the film Death Proof. I’ll be blunt: at least on first view, I loved it. While PT feels the most like it grew out of the “let’s make a grindhouse film!” conceit, DP feels like a film Tarantino would’ve made in any event, not as beholden to the gimmick. Plot-wise, it’s the slightest flick QT has done – Kurt Russell plays Stuntman Mike, a deranged stunt driver who likes to kill women in ways that look like car accidents, when there’s nothing accidental about them – but it’s actually emotional and, in its way, tragic. I think you could even analyze it: think about when Mike explains his job to a woman in the bar, and he calls her on not knowing the shows he’s worked on, and then notice that each group of women he targets includes a marginally well-known woman who’s still better known than Stuntman Mike is. Jealousy gone evil? Is that what’s happening? Do we see some hint of a sick, twisted motivation? Or is he just sick and twisted? But the roles are surprisingly meaty; Kurt Russell is clearly having a blast the likes of which may rival his work in his best John Carpenter films, and the women…
…thank God for the women. And thank God QT loves women. He drastically shifts the pace from PT’s chaos to something slower and quieter, opening his film with…women talking. Shooting the breeze. Having drinks, talking shop, indulging in their in-jokes, what-have-you. It’s generous for the actresses, and they run with it. He even gives Zoe Bell – the New Zealand stuntwoman who doubled for Uma Thurman in QT’s Kill Bill – her first fully on-screen role, as herself, or rather a Tarantino-processed version of herself. It’s a great debut.
There’s sex appeal in Grindhouse, oh my yes. Planet Terror’s is far jokier and more juvenile, the camera really ogling the female curves at times (insert crack about “rack focus” here), and when PT gives us a sex scene between Rose McGowan and Freddy Rodriguez, that scene is used to set up one of the film’s best meta-jokes. Death Proof’s, meanwhile, is a more all-encompassing, observant, strangely relaxed sex appeal; yes, it’s sometimes fetishistic (Tarantino loooooooves photographing women’s feet) but it’s a more mature, and definitely a very appreciative, form of fetishism. The eight female costars of DP are several different types of sexy (I think Rosario Dawson practically bends light towards herself), but their sense of humor, intelligence, easy-going camaraderie, and cheeky sense of both fun and risk-taking are a huge part of why they’re sexy. They’re interesting; or rather, they’re given a great chance to be interesting. And we get more invested in them as a result. It makes what happens to them tougher to watch: in the first car chase, when an already-dangerous situation escalates into terror (yes, I’m even avoiding spoilers in these loosely-plotted films), we worry that it might end badly for these characters; in PT, we don’t mind so much when things do end badly for many of those characters.
If the fake trailers in Grindhouse were my children, I’d have to say to them, “You see, I love each of you in much different ways.” The opening trailer for the fake film Machete immediately tells you how insane this whole enterprise is gonna be (my crowd’s first really huge laugh of the night came when we recognized the priest). In between PT and DP, we get more fake trailers: Rob Zombie’s Werewolf Women of the SS; a British Hammer-Haunted-House Horror flick by the director of Shaun of the Dead where the title is part of the joke, so I will not say it here (except to say that I thought, “No, they can’t make that the film’s title, can they?…Oh Cool, They Did!”); and the tits-and-ass-and-knives-and-blood-fest by Eli Roth called Thanksgiving. The fake trailers make such a perfect experience more, um, perfect-er, and each appeals to a different evil part of me: Thanksgiving’s cheerleader who strips while bouncing on a trampoline (you sick, sick man, Mr. Roth), Werewolf Women’s use of Nicolas Cage, and the whole Brit film thing (which I think is the one trailer from Grindhouse that has the best chance to actually be a good movie!).
Oh, finally: if