Chris Walsh (chris_walsh) wrote,
Chris Walsh
chris_walsh

Seriously.

Not to mention For Real:

Not every response to everything everywhere needs to be a joke.

I found it so wearying when a former housemate seemed to respond to 70% of everything said to him with a joke, or a crack, or some attempted cleverness. It was another way of Not Giving A Straight Answer, and he did it so much. It became a bad habit. It's like trying to make a whole meal out of Johnny's Salad Elegance: it's only tasty when combined with something substantial. AND SO LITTLE OF WHAT LEFT HIS MOUTH WAS SUBSTANTIAL.

In the past I've given up on certain writers for this particular reason: they sacrifice content and substance in what they're writing in order to try to be clever. And, usually, the attempted cleverness AIN'T CLEVER. That was one reason I finally stopped reading Pat Holmes, who I'd never liked from the first movie review I read but who I slogged through reading until I decided I'm getting nothing from reading this stuff; the hell with it. (I now pause for a Schaudenfreude alert! I didn't mind Holmes getting fired from the Portland Tribune last year. I was annoyed on behalf of fellow freelancer coffeeinhell, who got fired at the same time, but I've been a fan of hers since 2001 and a friend of hers since 2005, plus she's done fine since then...) It actually takes a lot for me to give up on reviewers I'm in the habit of reading; if the above is enough to make me abandon someone, it's probably a big deal to me.

What inspired this? Today I looked at the front page of the Sunday Oregonian's TV insert, paying more attention to it than normal because the front photo was of Eliza Dushku (I have a thing for her), and most of the front page's quick descriptions of upcoming TV shows were crack, crack, crack, none of them anywhere near funny. I hope they weren't written by The O's pop culture critic Peter Ames Carlin, and I doubt it: he's funnier, plus he has something to say.

Cleverness can be a seasoning, a wonderful tasty seasoning, but please, combine it with solid thoughts.

Clever (I hope) and serious (I hope),
chris_walsh

P.S. (not B.S.): I'm glad to say that you guys who I read on LiveJournal don't do that maddening thing. Thank you. Keep writing interesting stuff!
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 2 comments