Chris Walsh (chris_walsh) wrote,
Chris Walsh

FLASHBACKS: "The Synthesizer and the Odyssey," 6/9/1997

Not that this comes anywhere near beating the records of several friends of mine, but I can look online and find stuff I've written from 1997 on.

I did a bunch of spec work for Film Score Monthly's website back then (after I'd contributed three articles to FSM's print edition), and that stuff's still findable by searching. I'll link and share it.

Like my June 9th, 1997 sort-of-review of the miniseries version of The Odyssey.

The Synthesizer and the Odyssey
by Christopher Walsh

The miniseries edition of The Odyssey, happily, overcame the typical problems of translating literature to manageable size for TV; despite the Cliff's Notes story condensing, exceptionally poorly timed cuts to commercials the frequent cartoonishness of men-in-togas acting, the end result was a well-paced, beautifully shot ripping yarn. While the poetry of the original epic was left far behind -- what if someone filmed The Odyssey with no dialogue, to reflect some of the inherent abstraction of poetic structure? -- the moments of humanity in the acting made the changes worthwhile. Penelope's unraveling of the wedding shroud, usually presented as a calculated plan to delay the suitors' proposals, comes across here as an impetuous, impulsive yet instinctively correct moment. Some offbeat casting choices generally came off well (though Michael J. Pollard as squeaky- voiced "Gawd" Iolus became almost instantly grating); the special effects were for the most part excellent, though a poorly done serpent very early in the proceedings was almost a disaster; and the earthy Greek deities wisely were presented with interesting variety and never in the formal, God-in-the-clouds manner that Monty Python and the Holy Grail parodied so effectively 23 years ago. Quite simply, I had a good time with this telefilm.

The music by Edward Artemyev, however, was a misstep, a disappointing reminder of why the words "synth" and "dreck" are so frequently linked by our man Lukas [i.e. Lukas Kendall, the founder and editor of FSM]. The score seems the only part of the $40 million production -- a hefty price for television -- that was not lavishly done. An electronic ensemble tried to give the film an epic power, but offered no interesting aural associations and came off as a jarring attempt to save money. The only effective moments of the score came from live acoustic and ethnic instruments, suggesting this miniseries needed more archaic-sounding live music, much the way Michael Kamen originally hoped to score Robin Hood. Another hint of what-might-have-been was an acoustic, coiled "longing for Ithaca" theme, frequently played on ethnic instruments on Part Two. This melody, which I'd imagine Maurice Jarre would have been happy to write, nicely captured the simple pleasures which Odysseus missed so dearly (though Gretta Scacchi is more than a simple pleasure...).

Even with the especially crushing schedules one gets when scoring for miniseries, excellent music is possible; think of the successful scores for The Stand, Gettysburg, Masada and others. Also, the choice of Artemyev seems especially odd given the talent pool of capable composers which the producers of The Odyssey have tapped in recent years: Francis Ford Coppola got meaty scores from Kamen (Jack) and Wojciech Kilar (Bram Stoker's Dracula); Nicholas Meyer got muscular, moody work from Cliff Eidelman (Star Trek VI); and Robert Halmi, Sr. worked with Trevor Jones on Gulliver's Travels, some of Jones's best music in a long time. Director Andrei Konchalovsky has also worked with Jones, on the intense and thoughtful action drama Runaway Train; that film's blend of rock, chorus, Japanese flute and Vivaldi's Gloria built to a finale that is heartbreaking and triumphant at the same time. Given all of these potential scorers -- and add to this the fact that the completely different, StarGate-styled orchestral music was used in every single Odyssey promo and commercial break -- and we were continually reminded of the weakness of the final score. At least we can imagine the better music which The Odyssey deserved; I'm hearing various parts of Bram Stoker's Dracula as I try to do so.
Tags: film reviews, flashbacks, music

  • The Adventures of a Well-Known Film Composer, and Me

    Last night's dream was wistful and kind of lovely. And inspired by at least one real event. I was driving around a rural, semi-desert area much…

  • Abort, abort, abort

    My dreams in the middle of the night had some interesting imagery — at one point I was in a rich person's apartment, which had a button-operated…


    That was vivid. I dreamed I was staying in an immersive park, think Disney's Star Wars: Galaxy's Edge if it had lodging, and someone had decided…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.